Print

Navicular pain

Discussion topics for Painful Accessory Navicular Syndrome (ANS) can be categorized by its cause, diagnosis, non-surgical management, and surgical considerations.

1. Etiology and Pathophysiology

  • Congenital Nature and Asymptomatic Cases: Discuss the prevalence of the accessory navicular bone (AN) as a congenital anomaly and why most individuals with the extra bone remain asymptomatic.

  • Mechanism of Pain: Explore how the AN, its connection (synchondrosis) to the main navicular bone, and its relationship with the posterior tibial tendon (PTT) cause pain and inflammation in ANS.

  • Risk Factors and Triggers: Delve into the factors that can aggravate the condition, such as flat feet (pes planus), direct trauma (sprains), chronic irritation from footwear, and overuse/excessive activity.

  • Types of Accessory Navicular: Differentiate between the three main types of AN (Type I-III) and how each type might predispose a patient to symptoms.

2. Clinical Presentation and Diagnosis

  • Symptom Onset and Demographics: Discuss the common age of symptom onset, often in adolescence when the bone begins to ossify or due to increased sports activity.

  • Clinical Signs: Focus on the characteristic signs, including the palpable bony prominence on the medial midfoot, localized pain, swelling, and redness.

  • Diagnostic Challenges: Explore the difficulties in differential diagnosis, distinguishing ANS from other causes of medial foot pain (e.g., PTT dysfunction, navicular stress fracture).

  • Imaging Modalities: Compare the role and utility of different imaging tests:

    • X-rays: Confirmation of the AN's presence and type.

    • MRI: Assessing the status of the PTT and the inflammation/edema in the synchondrosis.

3. Non-Surgical Management Strategies

  • Conservative Care First: Emphasize the consensus that non-surgical treatment is the first line of management for ANS.

  • Immobilization and Rest: Discuss the use of non-weight-bearing periods, walking boots, or casts to allow the inflamed area to rest and heal.

  • Biomechanical Control: Analyze the importance of custom orthotic devices (arch supports) to reduce strain on the PTT and support the arch, thereby minimizing irritation of the AN.

  • Physical Therapy and Rehabilitation: Detail the role of physical therapy, including exercises for PTT strengthening, ankle stabilization, and calf stretching to reduce deforming forces on the midfoot.

  • Pharmacological and Injection Therapy: Review the use of Non-Steroidal Anti-Inflammatory Drugs (NSAIDs) and the indications/risks of steroid injections into the painful area.

4. Surgical Intervention and Outcomes

  • Indications for Surgery: Discuss the criteria for determining when conservative treatment has failed and surgical intervention is necessary (e.g., persistent pain that limits daily activity).

  • Surgical Procedures: Detail the typical surgical procedure, which involves excision (removal) of the accessory bone and, often, reattachment of the posterior tibial tendon to the main navicular bone.

  • Post-Operative Rehabilitation: Explore the recovery timeline, including the use of immobilization and the structured physical therapy required to restore full function and strength.

  • Long-Term Outcomes and Complications: Discuss the expected success rate of surgery, potential complications (e.g., nerve irritation, wound healing issues, continued pain), and the impact of the surgery on normal foot function.